Black People : The government’s herd immunity plan is callous and dangerous


Jul 2, 2003
The United States, Brazil, And The United Kingdom
have Ding Dongs in Charge
Along with much citizenry that believe. in all these countries and are going along with this Herd Immunity Crap.. .
Purposefully refusing to wear protection.... Feelings nothing even if it is by other means besides the Virus that lives are lost.

" Nuke Em and Let God sort Them Out "
Or Let the Virus eliminate the Weak and Fragile and Only the Strong Shall Survive.

Either Way this is why the PPE and Testing kits are not available, States are left to fend for themselves etc..

The government’s herd immunity plan is callous and dangerous

We have not been told why such a policy by contrast is not appropriate for the UK. Given the pitifully low level of intensive care unit facilities and trained ICU staff here, it would seem even more critical for our country that the spread of the virus is not merely managed as an epidemiological case study, but stopped before the NHS is completely overwhelmed, as it will be at the levels of infection calmly being predicted by the government and its advisers.

The approach looks dangerously like callous complacency rather than urgent emergency intervention. If carnage unfolds, we will look to the experience of other countries, and if we have a significantly higher death rate than others, our government will not be forgiven.
Stephen Smith


The UK government’s strategy to minimise the impact of Covid-19 “is to allow the virus to pass through the entire population so that we acquire herd immunity”. Implicit in this is the acceptance of large numbers of deaths of vulnerable people, hence Boris Johnson saying that many families will lose loved ones. This sounds dangerously like what Malthus described in 1798 as “positive checks”, which lead to premature death from disease, starvation and war, resulting in what is called a Malthusian catastrophe. In contrast, nearly every other government in Europe is pursuing a different strategy – one of containment. For once, the phrase “being ahead of the curve”, has deep meaning.
Tom Conroy
Dublin, Ireland

It has long been obvious that Boris Johnson exists in a moral vacuum, but to propose a public policy that tacitly accepts the potential death of thousands of people is beyond shameful and, equally so, to try to minimise its impact as the loss of loved ones before their time. Not only should we question the scientific validity of herd immunity, which the World Health Organization rejects, but also its morality. No wonder the rest of the world is looking with incredulity at the UK government’s response to Covid-19.
Alan Walker

Professor of social policy, University of Sheffield

• There is a reason why doctors take the Hippocratic oath. Now when key decisions on coronavirus are made by politicians, perhaps they should take it too. If herd immunity works, it will be at the cost of avoidable deaths – of patients, health workers and doctors. If it doesn’t work, we will have a social experiment that failed, at the cost of many human lives. Boris Johnson said that “many more families are going to lose loved ones before their time”. He should have finished his sentence with “and many of those deaths are avoidable”.

Other countries aren’t doing this, for good reason. If one of my friends or family die under this policy, I will seriously look at crowdfunding a judicial review. I think we should do everything possible to change this heartless and arrogant approach.
Amanda Edwards
Velindre, Llandysul

• Tony Yates quotes Patrick Vallance, the chief scientific adviser, as explaining part of the reason for not embracing bans (on gatherings) is to encourage “herd immunity”. Surely this is a misinterpretation of what herd immunity is? Before the polio vaccine was developed people got polio. They didn’t get herd immunity. Herd immunity is predicated on vaccination and it is the vaccinated who constitute the herd, not those with the disease. No vaccine just means more disease, not more immunity. This seems like a dangerous misunderstanding for one in such a pivotal role to make.
Dr Andrew Platman
GP retired, Beckenham, Kent

• Your correspondents (Show us the evidence behind Covid-19 policies, Journal, 14 March) are justified in their scepticism of the government’s response to Covid-19; Boris Johnson and his colleagues haven’t always been transparent on other matters. However, I do trust the chief medical officer (CMO) and chief scientific adviser (CSA) – expert clinician-scientists – and they appear to be leading decision-making at the moment.

The CMO and CSA are wrestling with complex, contradictory, partial and rapidly-changing data, and formulating recommendations as best they can. Of course, there’s a debate to be had as to why experts in other countries are initiating more severe restrictions, and more transparency on the modelling information being used would be welcome. More proscriptive actions come with significant risks of their own. For example, closing schools will potentially remove parents employed in health and social care from the workforce at this critical time and/or expose grandparents (the most vulnerable demographic) to risk of increased viral exposure if they take on childcare responsibilities.

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Writeous1 Black People : Hoax at the Capitol - When Hollywood Meets Government Black People Open Forum 21
HODEE Black People : Ventilator Supplier _ In New York _ They Could Fix the Incomplete Ones Sent to New York By the Government Black People Open Forum 0
C Black People : America Is No Democracy Of The Republic Government!!! Black People Open Forum 0
dattaswami1 Black Spirituality Religion : Is is right to pay taxes to a corrupt government? Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 8
OldSoul Black People : Government Paid Reparations For Italian Americans Who Were Lynched Black People Open Forum 0
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : To the president: a government class fought for the release of unsolved FBI civil rights case files African American History Culture 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Liberia : Liberian journalists alarmed over government 'hostilities' Liberia 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Jails / Prisons : US government gave Nation of Islam hundreds of thousands of dollars to teach federal prison inmates Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Cameroon : Jailed Cameroon writer who criticized government to be expelled - lawyer Cameroon 1
Clyde C Coger Jr Science and Technology : Is Apple About to Accidentally Kill Government as Platform? Science and Technology 1
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : A 'Forgotten History' Of How The U.S. Government Segregated America African American History Culture 0
Destee Namibia : Namibia's government considering seizing land from foreign and white owners Namibia 0
RAPTOR Black People Politics : Yvette Carnelle: "Government Ain't Never Did Nothing for Black People" is a lie Black People Politics 5
jamesfrmphilly Black Positive People : michael-bennett-nfl-not-going-on israel-government-trip- Black People Doing Positive Things 2
S Black People Politics : Why Democrats Got Wiped Out At Every Level Of Government In The Last Election Black People Politics 0
Liberty Food Discussion : This is How the Government is Subsidizing Coke & Pepsi Food Discussion and Recipes 1
Queenie Black People : 10 Ways the Government Could Be Spying on You Black People Open Forum 3
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : Here's How The Nation Responded When A Black Militia Group Occupied A Government Building African American History Culture 2
RAPTOR Egypt : U.S. Government Celebrates Its Arming of the Egyptian Regime... Egypt 1
TruthHitman African American History Culture : Government target memorandum of March 4, 1968 to “Prevent the Rise of a Messiah” among Black People African American History Culture 1
A Black People : Your ideal culture, society and government Black People Open Forum 1
crwn Black People : Government Thievery Black People Open Forum 0
John Williams Black People Politics : Is the U.S. government's "Selective Service" system sexist? Black People Politics 14
Destee Black People : Do You Have Any Suggestions for Detroit's Water Situation Besides Begging the Government? Black People Open Forum 70
Fine1952 Black People : White People Make Up 42% of the Poor, But Take in Whopping 69% of Government Benefits Black People Open Forum 13
Chevron Dove Black Christians : WHITE SUPREMACIST GOVERNMENT & The Set Up~ ZECHARIAH 5 Christian Study Group 0
KingSango Black People Politics : The American Government is White Supremacy: Not just Skinheads and Nazis. Black People Politics 1
I Black People Politics : Video of White American government official openly talking about UFOs & their (UFOs) occupants Black People Politics 3
HODEE Black People : There is, no powers conferred on the Federal Government so Liable to Abuse as the Taxing Powers. Black People Open Forum 0
Keita Kenyatta Black People : Government ADMITS secretly SPRAYING POISON on us!!! Black People Open Forum 0
RAPTOR Black People : The Speculative Endgame: The Government “Shutdown” and “Debt Default”, A Multibillion Bonanza for Wa Black People Open Forum 0
Destee Law Forum : Web Sites Seized and/or Shutdown by Government Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 19
Destee Black People Politics : Is The Government Gonna Shutdown Tonight? .... uuuhhhh .... yeah ... :) Black People Politics 52
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : World holds breath as US government shutdown imminent Black People Politics 16
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : Leading U.S. House Democrat sees tough fight over government shutdown Black People Politics 0
Alarm Clock Black People Politics : UN says that invesitgators find that Chemical weapons used by Syrian rebels, not the government Black People Politics 3
RAPTOR Black People Politics : Obama Turns Federal Workers Into Snitches:"straight out of fascist models of government&behavior" Black People Politics 1
Chevron Dove Black People Politics : Israeli State Government Practice EUGENICS Against Original 'Black' Israelite Women Black People Politics 0
Latik Allah Nation of Gods and Earths : Supreme Government/Godvernment Nation of Gods and Earths Study Group 0
Alarm Clock Ghana : Ghana Government Orders Illegal Chinese Miners to Leave Ghana 9
Destee Black People Politics : Collecting rainwater now illegal in many states as Big Government claims ownership over our water Black People Politics 6
Destee Black People Politics : What is the Oldest Government Still in Existence Today? Black People Politics 39
Destee Black People Politics : What is the Process for Starting Your Own Government? Black People Politics 18
Destee Black People Politics : What is the Best - Already Established Government - On The Planet? Black People Politics 23
blazejay Black People Politics : Is America ready for a new form of government? Black People Politics 6
A Black People : The U.S. Government Found Guilty Of Killing Martin Luther King jr. 13 Years Ago? Black People Open Forum 1
Mad Skillz Haiti : The U.S. Government Stopped a Minimum Wage Increase in Haiti Pan-Africanism - African Diaspora 5
AACOOLDRE Brother AACOOLDRE : When the government wants to kill AACOOLDRE 0
river Black People Politics : Government Attack on the Working Class Black People Politics 1
Destee Black People : Website / Domain Seized by Federal Government !!! Black People Open Forum 4
Similar threads

Latest profile posts

sekou kasimu wrote on ZIbijah's profile.
Have you read "The Iceman Inheritance: Prehistoric Origins of Western Man's Racism, Sexism, and Aggression"?
$1 Billion Black dollars in 30 days
Destee wrote on Marcchris's profile.
Hi @Marcchris ... Welcome Welcome Welcome!!! :wave: ... Thanks for joining us AND becoming a Premium Member! :cheerleader: ... I am honored. Please make yourself right at home! Much Love and Peace.
Destee wrote on rhymebad's profile.
I Love You! :love:
Destee wrote on dunwiddat's profile.
Good to see you Sister! :cheerleader: