Law Forum : Should an Attorney Always Be Requested

Destee

destee.com
STAFF
Jan 22, 2001
35,905
9,861
betwixt and between
destee.com
Occupation
Website Consultant
Peace and Blessings Family,

I see the tv shows, like 48 hours and such, and many of our people are displayed on there, being interrogated for crimes that will cost them the rest of their lives, and they never ask for an attorney!

I know we're not attorneys and stuff ... but uuhhhhh ... shouldn't folk always ask for an attorney?

:heart:

Destee
 

LindaChavis

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Feb 11, 2007
1,213
140
Columbus, Ohio
Occupation
Car Sales Consultant
Article I found relevant.....

Court: Suspects can be interrogated without lawyer

By JESSE J. HOLLAND
Associated Press Writer


WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Supreme Court on Tuesday overturned a long-standing ruling that stopped police from initiating questions unless a defendant's lawyer was present, a move that will make it easier for prosecutors to interrogate suspects.

The high court, in a 5-4 ruling, overturned the 1986 Michigan v. Jackson ruling, which said police may not initiate questioning of a defendant who has a lawyer or has asked for one unless the attorney is present. The Michigan ruling applied even to defendants who agreed to talk to the authorities without their lawyers.

The court's conservatives overturned that opinion, with Justice Antonin Scalia saying "it was poorly reasoned."

Under the Jackson opinion, police could not even ask a defendant who had been appointed a lawyer if he wanted to talk, Scalia said.

"It would be completely unjustified to presume that a defendant's consent to police-initiated interrogation was involuntary or coerced simply because he had previously been appointed a lawyer," Scalia said in the court's opinion.

Scalia, who read the opinion from the bench, said the decision will have "minimal" effects on criminal defendants because of the protections the court has provided in other decisions. "The considerable adverse effect of this rule upon society's ability to solve crimes and bring criminals to justice far outweighs its capacity to prevent a genuinely coerced agreement to speak without counsel present," Scalia said.

The Michigan v. Jackson opinion was written by Justice John Paul Stevens, the only current justice who was on the court at the time. He and Justices David Souter, Stephen Breyer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg dissented from the ruling, and in an unusual move Stevens read his dissent aloud from the bench. It was the first time this term a justice had read a dissent aloud.

"The police interrogation in this case clearly violated petitioner's Sixth Amendment right to counsel," Stevens said. Overruling the Jackson case, he said, "can only diminish the public's confidence in the reliability and fairness of our system of justice."

The Obama administration had asked the court to overturn Michigan v. Jackson, disappointing civil rights and civil liberties groups that expected President Barack Obama to reverse the policies of his Republican predecessor, George W. Bush.

The Justice Department, in a brief signed by Solicitor General Elena Kagan, said the 1986 decision "serves no real purpose" and offers only "meager benefits." The government said defendants who don't wish to talk to police don't have to and that officers must respect that decision. But it said there is no reason a defendant who wants to should not be able to respond to officers' questions.

Eleven states also echoed the administration's call to overrule the 1986 case.

The decision comes in the case of Jesse Jay Montejo, who was found guilty in 2005 of the shooting death of Louis Ferrari in the victim's home on Sept. 5, 2002.

Montejo was appointed a public defender at his Sept. 10, 2002 hearing, but never indicated that he wanted the lawyer's help. Montejo then went with police detectives to help them look for the murder weapon. While in the car, Montejo wrote a letter to Ferrari's widow incriminating himself.

When they returned to the prison, a public defender was waiting for Montejo, irate that his client had been questioned in his absence. Police used the letter against Montejo at trial, and he was convicted and sentenced to death. He appealed, but the Louisiana Supreme Court upheld the conviction and sentence.

The Supreme Court sent the case back for a determination of whether any of Montejo's other court-provided protections, like his Miranda rights, were violated.

The case is Montejo v. Louisiana, 07-1529.

© 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. Learn more about our Privacy Policy.
 

Shikamaru

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
May 7, 2011
3,444
1,960
It depends on the situation as well as how much knowledge you have on that area or aspect of law whether you should request an attorney or not.

Acceptance of an attorney places the client under wardship and patronage of the attorney (as well as the court being the attorney is an officer of the court).
 

skuderjaymes

Contextualizer Synthesizer
MEMBER
Nov 2, 2009
8,782
5,852
theory to application to discussion to percussion
Occupation
independent thoughtist thinker, context linker
Peace and Blessings Family,

I see the tv shows, like 48 hours and such, and many of our people are displayed on there, being interrogated for crimes that will cost them the rest of their lives, and they never ask for an attorney!

I know we're not attorneys and stuff ... but uuhhhhh ... shouldn't folk always ask for an attorney?

:heart:

Destee

I watch those shows too.. the only cases that make it to the screen are the
ones that don't lawyer up so it gives the impression that no one asks for a
lawyer.. I wish they would do like law and order and follow the case all the
way through.. that aside.. I think those shows highlight the overwhelming
desire to confess.. they seem to be relieved after they let it out.. like their
is some sort of weight lifted.. even with a lawyer most of them take Plea-
bargains..

but to answer the question.. I say, yes.. if you are innocent. If you are
guilty, you deserve whatever you get.​
 

Kemetstry

going above and beyond
PREMIUM MEMBER
Feb 19, 2001
27,581
7,927
Detroit
Occupation
Chemist
Peace and Blessings Family,

I see the tv shows, like 48 hours and such, and many of our people are displayed on there, being interrogated for crimes that will cost them the rest of their lives, and they never ask for an attorney!

I know we're not attorneys and stuff ... but uuhhhhh ... shouldn't folk always ask for an attorney?

:heart:

Destee


If they have any sense












:em0200:


 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
G Black People Politics : Toppling Statues and Removing Racist State Flags Should Not be The legacy of The Untimely Demise of George Floyd Black People Politics 0
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : What Does BIPOC Stand For? Here’s Why You Should Consider Using the Term to Be More Inclusive African American History Culture 1
A Black Spirituality Religion : What books/tools should a person use to study the old testament? Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 1
candeesweet Black Poetry : Should I wonder? Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 4
M Black People : How should I put it? Black People Open Forum 4
Clyde C Coger Jr African American History Culture : The Enlightenment’s Dark Side How the Enlightenment created modern race thinking, and why we should confront it African American History Culture 0
HODEE Black People Politics : Americans should prepare for coronavirus crisis in U.S., CDC says Black People Politics 5
OldSoul Black People : Global Warning by OldSoul (written in Spoken Word and should be read aloud to oneself and with others) Black People Open Forum 0
Ndugu Black People : No Reason Why we should not have a Nationwide Boycott on Black Friday ova Police Lynching! Black People Open Forum 1
Chyko Black Relationships : Black Women Should Allow Black Men To Have Side Chicks – Mo’Nique Black Relationships 4
C Black People : When You Are Thinking Divinely, Then You Are Naturally Behaving As You Should!!! Black People Open Forum 0
R Black Poetry : Head not at odds it's straight and in Genesis now god create the HEAVEN AND EARTH folks should be in FT LEAVENWORTH for not believing, the earth had n Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 2
Clyde C Coger Jr Black Education / Schools : All college students should take a mandatory course on black history and white privilege Black Education / Schools 1
Clyde C Coger Jr Africa : Should museums return their colonial artifacts? All Things Africa 0
Destee Black People : Should We Allow the N Word to Be Used Here? Why or Why Not? Vote in the Poll Please. Black People Open Forum 69
dattaswami1 Black Christians : A true devotee must always express that the will of God should always happen either in his case or in the case of the others Christian Study Group 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Vegetable - Fruit - Recipe : How to Actually Remove Pesticides From Your Fruit Assuming that you should be worried about them in the first place Food Discussion and Recipes 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Science and Technology : The Earth is wobbling more than it should, and humans are likely the cause Science and Technology 0
A Black Spirituality Religion : What scriptures from the old testament should a person read to become a better man? Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 1
DigitallyBlack Black Picture Image Gallery : Train up a child in the way s/he should go: and when s/he is old, s/he will not depart from it. Black Picture Image Gallery 0
A Black Spirituality Religion : How should a beginner approach the old testament? Black Spirituality / Religion - General Discussion 4
Kemetstry Black People : WHY WE SHOULD NEVER LET GO OR FORGET Black People Open Forum 12
R Black Poetry : HE SAID: Hood made want good grades should’ve played foot-ball yall now in the mall to think about t Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 1
R Black Poetry : HE SAID: Hood made want good grades should’ve played foot-ball yall now in the mall to think about t Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 2
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : Why Oprah Should Not Run for President Black People Politics 17
chuck Black People Politics : What Should Be Our Goal For True African-American Political Empowerment In 2018? Black People Politics 1
Mister Aten Black Money Business Jobs : Bitcoin:Should we trust it? Black Money Business Jobs 21
Kemetstry Science and Technology : SCIENTIST SAY, UNIVERSE SHOULD NOT EXIST Science and Technology 2
chuck African American History Culture : What Should We Tell Today's Black Youth About The Black Freedom Fighters of the Seventies? African American History Culture 2
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People : A firing that should have stuck Black People Open Forum 0
AACOOLDRE Brother AACOOLDRE : Should blacks celebrate the fourth of July AACOOLDRE 5
Clyde C Coger Jr Food Discussion : Coconut oil's health benefits are a myth — here's what you should buy instead Food Discussion and Recipes 1
freddie419 Black Poetry : Heroes Should Never Replace Your Dad Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 0
Liberty Food Discussion : Fruits and Vegetables - Why You Should Make an Extra Effort to Eat More Food Discussion and Recipes 3
Clyde C Coger Jr Health and Wellness : High Blood Pressure? 22 Foods You Should Avoid as Much as Possible Black Health and Wellness 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Somalia : After The SOMALI MASSACRE, Should We Sell More Arms To The Saudis? Somalia 4
Senegal Black People Politics : This Is Why We Should #Buy Black and #Bank Black Black People Politics 18
Liberty Black People Politics : President Trump Should Consider CBC Budget If He’s Serious about Helping Black America Black People Politics 3
Clyde C Coger Jr Health and Wellness : Bottled water overtakes soda as America’s No. 1 drink — why you should avoid both Black Health and Wellness 0
jamesfrmphilly Law Forum : jeff-sessions-should-resign Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 3
Clyde C Coger Jr Black Money Business Jobs : 5 Things You Should Never Buy at Walmart Black Money Business Jobs 2
Clyde C Coger Jr Health and Wellness : 10 Foods Everyone With High Blood Pressure Should Be Eating 22 Foods You Should Avoid Black Health and Wellness 8
AACOOLDRE Brother AACOOLDRE : Frederick Douglas: And the 4th of July Trump should read this AACOOLDRE 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Black Entertainment : Why 'Hidden Figures' is a Movie Everyone Should Watch Black Entertainment 13
chuck Black People : We Should Hold Our Black News Editors And Black News Reporters Accountable Too! Black People Open Forum 0
1poetsought Black Poetry : America Should Black Poetry - Get Your Flow On! 3
crwn Black People Politics : Should these be added to the "Clinton Body Count"? Black People Politics 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : 2016 should make us rethink our approach to politicians Black People Politics 31
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : Nick Cannon Won’t Vote for President but He Thinks You Should Black People Politics 0
Greatest I am Black Education / Schools : Those who pay for education should consider the benefits of a bonus system for students. Black Education / Schools 2
Similar threads


















































Destee Chat

Latest profile posts

Life is just a breath, but your works last forever.
@Destee
During this time, I wanna to wish everyone on this site the most blesseth and positive energy throughout
the rest of 2020 as we continue to persevere and raise awareness during this plandemic.
Continue to stay safe
and healthy. We're in the perfect time to self-care and boost our immune systems through at home remedies.
@Destee
I know this is my first status update since 2020 begin, but all of us agree that 2020 delivered a low-blow
to each of us with the miscellaneous events we have recently seen which brought all of us great displeasure.
Destee wrote on Joyce's profile.
Thanks for the Blessing! Love You! :kiss:
Making sure I do more than I did yesterday. Progress is the Concept.
Top