Black People : Legalizing Illegal Immigrants..the Republican Plan to replace the Black Community?


Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2002
The Diaspora
Brothers and Sisters I want to call attention to a Bush proposal to grant temporary working rights to the country's estimated 10 million illegal immigrants (the majority of whom are from Mexico). Under this plan, immigrant workers can apply for 3 year work grants, under which they can stay in the country without the fear of deportation. This plan also gives immigrants the right to travel to & from the country. While immigrants are not automatically granted green cards, the process will become much easier. They can also continue to re-apply for subsequent 3 year work grants, if they do not have a green card when their work grant expires. In other words as long as an immigrant has a job, they can stay in the country forever!

This plan which Bush intends to introduce to the nation today (Jan 7, 2004), has HUGE ramifications for Black people. As everyone knows the economy is already in a depression (in my mind we passed the recession phase a year ago). Thousands of people are getting layed off monthly, many of whom are black, and many of whom struggle to find new employment. In a time where literally thousands of US citizens (both white and black) are struggling to find employment, it is sick to grant employment rights to illegal workers. Although this negatively effects many Americans it mostly affects us. For the last 20 years Latinos have taken jobs which used to historically go to Black people. Janitorial services and meatpacking (while menial work) used to be dominated by a unionized well paid black labor force. Now however they are dominated by a non-unionized immigrant labor force, who I might add have decreased the pay for these positions. For those of you who live in an area that is heavily populated by Latinos I'm sure you will have noticed that jobs which once went to Blacks (like fast food, retail, car sales), and now going to Latinos. I'm sure you that you have noticed that low income loans and housing programs that once focused on Blacks are mostly going to Latinos. All of this would be a positive if it meant that Blacks as a community are moving up in society, but that isn't the case.

What I see happening is a Bush/Republican agenda to further increase their power by catering to potential Latino voters, and at the same time to further castrate Black America. I've always felt that the number of blacks who are imprisoned served two purposes: When people are jailed they lose their suffrage (voting) right, and in many cases their employment rights. By jailing millions of Blacks (men & women), the political & economic power of the Black Community is severly dimenished. Legalizing millions of illegals furthers this trend. We all know that the last presidential election was decided by only 400 votes. Latinos (Cubans) in Florida are credited with being the deciding factor in the 2000 election. Many of whom switched from Democratic from Republican over the Elian Gonzalez issue. With Latinos surpassing the Black population (many of whom don't vote), and if Republicans win over the Latino vote, they will have all the votes they will need to say in office for years to come. If a presidential administration (or state/county) does not need the black vote to stay in office, then it does not need to address our needs. If a political administration does not need the black vote to obtain an office.....then it WILL NOT address our needs. We are witnessing a covert attempt to remove Black America as a relevant sector of the US!

While I have mainly focused on Republicans, in truth Democrats can very well do the same thing. This is further proof that it is almost impossible for Black people as group to American society. Our fate is not in our hands, as long as we continue to comply with the standard political/economic structure. It is also further proof of the need for black employers, and ultimately a United States of Africa (see the PanAfrican forum). As long as we continue to rely on whites for employment we will continue to be subject to their whim (passed over for who they see fit). In the mean time however, we need to mobilize and vote in mass this coming election. We need to express our concerns to politicians in our community, and replace any (including sellout blacks) who aren't working for us. We need to start investing in our own communities. But most importantly we need to Wake UP!

Flow Like That

Dec 31, 2003
Good post Panafrica.

In 1991 I attended a presentation by Dr. Claud Anderson. What's Ironic is the fact Dr. Anderson predicted exactly what you have so eloquently stated in your thread - that illegal immigration and lobbyist for illegal immigration within the government would marginalize the Black economic/voting structure to the point of irrelevancy. Sadly though truth is coming to light. In a nutshell, Balck people wont be needed to keep this country going. This one red flag should be our wake up call to many issues that we face.

As Black people we seriously need to design a plan of action for our more business as more foolish efforts to assimilate with white people. A bitter pill we may need to take and drastic changes made to see results. Discussing Dr. Andersons Powernomics is something I would like to do one day on this forum.

I for one have my own method of contribution to our people. Currently I work in real estate - a Black owned company I might add. My goal is to get Blacks into homes. If they don't qualify I try to get them qualified. Although I will sell a home to anyone (money is money) my personal disposition is to target Black people. I truly believe Black home ownership is the first step to economic independence. I have witnessed countless times Asians who work in real estate go that extra mile to sell to other Asians...which many are recent immigrants owning homes. They use a concerted effort to assist one another. If Black people can adopt a similar philosophy in their own professions this could be a small but important step to unify the Black power structure.

When I first started out in real estate I worked for Mr. Charlie. Blatant discrimination is practiced by white owned mortgage and real estate companies when it comes to minority home ownership and re-financing.

An important step for our survival is to build and support more Black owned businesses. If Blacks can't get results from white owned companies then we must build our own institutions to satisfy our needs.


going above and beyond
Feb 9, 2001
Excellent thread topic

I can recall when the Berlin Wall was destroyed, there was another prediction that America would experience an influx of Europeans with high tech skills thereby threatening job opportunities for American workers competing for the same jobs. Because American industries haven't done a good job over the years to develop the skills of their employees helping to keep them competitive, as we moved from the industrial age to the information age, demand for low-tech skills has drastically decreased as demand for high-tech skills have sky-rocketed. Over 20 years ago I read a book titled, "Workforce 2000: Work and Workers for the 21st Century" where this was accurately predicted based on studies of economic and industry trends back in the 1980s.

So this Bush/Republican agenda is nothing new. The plan has been in place for many years and has never been a secret. The problem is that Blacks have had so much on their plates to deal with, it's extremely difficult to juggle so many of our issues. Maybe our focus has been more on arguing for equality under the law and assimilating after integration that we failed to see the subtle and not so subtle changes taking place around us every day that would make the gap even wider.

What this new proposal is, is an squeeze play. On one end, immigrants from less developed countries coming to America desperately seeking jobs--any kind of job--will have just as much of an impact on Blacks in their struggle for employment as will the high tech engineers running from political/economic oppression. Are Blacks caught in the middle of this scenario? Sure we are, so what else is new?

In order for a country like America to work it's plan to sit at the top of world domination and have ultimate power, it needs worker bees. The vast majority of those producing manual labor--people doing mindless and mundane tasks day in and day out paying wages that barely help them to survive--will be Blacks and Latinos. The high end of the spectrum will be those whose skills can be pimped to the highest degree--courted by high wages and other shiny trinkets, in exchange for their brains--by the government and industries to help the country maintain its military and economic power.

I think we're awake already and I think we see the handwriting on the wall. We're not stupid--we know very well what's happening. But like it's been written so many times in a number of threads, something is wrong that keeps us paralyzed such that we don't come together to do anything about it. Individually, many of us have tried and continue to try. Some of us have gotten tired of waiting for the mass movement to take place and have decided to make it the best way we can. Thus you see a sprinkling of us at the "top" of the economic scale. We keep saying what we should do to support each other, yet we still aren't doing it. You think if we keep saying it enough, it will eventually sink in?

Peace! :spinstar:


Well-Known Member
May 3, 2002
Vote and Stop

we have no choice but to get out and vote; with the mindset that whomever we vote for probably will not really do anything to help us; so all we can do is vote on issues that in someway are seemingly fair-minded...
As devastating as the "writing on the wall has been" for a very long time, mind you; and as long as we have discussed this issue amongst others; it is time that we either sink or swim collectively.... or die apart.

Flow Like That, makes a great point when she illustrates the tribal tactics of Asians; those same tactics transcend into every other ethnicity, and race in America, excepet for US. What is ironic, is that EVERYBODY knows that this is how communities work with each other...they understand that helping each other is helping themselves.... and they know how to keep "what is happening in their houses, in their houses." We are the only ones who prefer ACCEPTANCE over EMPOWERMENT...seemingly. But, on the other hand, I have found many Black Americans who say that they want US to unite and learn to help each other, and stop being susceptible to divionary tactics perpetrated on US by White America; but find some of US- people they don't want to deal with (Two-faced Blacks, Self-hating Blacks, etc...) But, then one could argue that Whites and Others disrespect US, mistreat US, use US and abuse US--- yet, we still patronize them... Funny thing is that Whites and others do not patronize US, and we still KISSING ***, AND HOPING FOR LOVE. I don't know, maybe it is that hatred of US sting moreso, when we do those things to each other, and makes it easier to cut ties with such a person?

For Black Americans, jobs that WE do not create for OURSELVES are tenuous at best, as someone stated, WE are at the whim of people who historically have not and will not have OUR best interest at heart. WE are creators and thinkers. WE create for everyone BUT ourselves. WE still have a collective bargaining chip. WE have to think and improve OUR skills, and stop telling OUR enemies what we are doing or are trying to do.

Just as we need to stop patronizing work places that do not hire US; especially if they are Black American entities (what, didn't know that WE possessed that kind of Negro?); WE have to stop patronizing whole industries... EX: if Black women would use just their dollars, say on fashion, of which WE spend on average, $1,000/ month, according to published reports-- and stop and save it; or if you gotta buy, direct those funds to Black American designers, who in turn support US... that can make a huge dent, and since actions do speak louder than words... all will be said; then take that movement and channel it to every thing... You want to protest illegal immigration, stop buying--- and not one word will have to be said. What is ironic about this is that me being Black ; this is somehow going to translate into being wrong--- yet, it is the very thing that White America; who is the least affected by the situation, is doing; on Jan. 12 they have geared up to stop buying anything.... some orgs. say Jan. 9-12 don't buy anything, or pay any bills. Year before last, they started requiring contractors who would build their homes to disclose the ethnicity of their labor force.... and no one said that it was wrong.

Our hypocrisy and self-sabotage is Our biggest problem.


Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2002
The Diaspora
First of all I'd like to acknowledge and express gratitude towards Flow Like That for the work that she does (helping to increase black homeownership). This is sorely needed in our community, and is a source of untold power. I'd also like to hear more about what Dr. Claud Anderson had to say about this issue back in 1991. The immigration issue (I want to go on record as saying that I only have a problem with illegal immigration, not immigration in general) was not even a blip on my radar back then.....actually I was still in high school at that time. However that is an important time, because it was around that period when the current influx of South American immigrants started to flood the country.

I remember that I first started to notice the amount of Latinos coming into the country around 1996/97. I grew up in Illinois (Maywood & Bolingbrook), and although there pockets of Latinos in the neighborhood, no large community existed. I left Illinois in 1994 to attend college in Maryland, and when I came back to visit family I noticed that there were a lot of Latinos in the neighborhood. I didn't necessarily notice them in houses, but I went to Burger King and the entire store was Latino. I went to Taco Bell and McDonald's and noticed the same thing. The same with K-mart and that used to belong to Blacks now were occupied with Latinos. I remember thinking "wow, how can a neighborhood change so rapidly"? While I wondered with curiosity what brought about the change in my old neighborhood, I really got a lesson in the scale of illegal immigration, and the impact it has on Black workers when I moved to NYC in 2000.

In NYC Latinos were the dominant minority everywhere I went (statistically they are the largest minority in New York, New Jersey, Texas, and they practically own California). Many could not speak English, or did so very poorly. But they dominated the local economy. They either owned businesses (where they didn't, and don't hire blacks I might add) or were the 1st hired at the major corporations. For a Black person to get a decent job in many areas of NYC, they had better be able to speak Spanish, or they would have a hard time. This was especially true for Education, which I had recently got my degree in. People who were spanish speaking got hired almost immediately, while those who weren't had to fight fierce competition to get a job. In education I got a glimpse of just how many of these kids were illegals (and subsequently how many of their parents were illegal). I got further indications after speaking with people in the community and watching Spanish Television Networks like Telemundo (which regularly talks about how to get green cards/work permission, how to stay in the country illegally, how to get housing, etc). Most importantly though I observed how Blacks were struggling while the Latino community in NYC were prospering in comparison. Many of these Blacks were either losing their jobs to illegal workers, or being turned away from industries because the average wage had been driven below livable wages, due to a steady supply of illegal labor. It was after observing this that I knew that something has to be done to protect the interest of the Black Community.

I said earlier that I didn't have a problem with legal immigrants, I'd also like to say I don't have a problem with Latinos in general. However they do not have the same agenda as us, and it is a mistake to assume they do. This mistake was made by our so-called leaders in the 1980s & 90s, who sought Latino membership in the NAACP and other Civil Right organizations. The theory behind this recruitment was that since Latinos aren't white, and are discriminated against then they are on our side. This was a foolish assumption because the biggest concerns of Latinos are the legalization of illegals and bi-lingual education programs (neither of which are important to the black community). The few goals that we have in comon: obtaining housing and employment, we are in direct competition for. In short. Latinos joined these organizations, reaped the benefits of our efforts on their behalf, then went in there own direction. While we are left wondering what happened.

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
chuck Black People Politics : Legalizing It All Seems and Sounds Like Another Cop Out! Black People Politics 26
HODEE Black People : New lockdown laws in England make it illegal for couples living apart to have sex indoors Black People Open Forum 0
Clyde C Coger Jr Jails / Prisons : Texas Mom Sentenced To Jail For Illegal Voting Says She Refuses To Be Intimidated Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 0
Mr_Harry Black People Politics : Black People and Illegal Aliens Black People Politics 27
Kemetstry Law Forum : ILLEGAL SEARCH AND SEIZURE Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 1
Destee Black People Politics : Donald Trump considering pardoning Joe Arpaio for his illegal reign of racist terror Black People Politics 15
Liberty Law Forum : Mississippi African Americans besieged by illegal searches, ACLU lawsuit says Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 41
Taylor949 Black People : Illegal immigration affecting black communities Black People Open Forum 31
Liberty Black People Politics : Do You Believe Illegal Immigration Hurts African-Americans? Black People Politics 38
Aluku Black People Politics : Real Talk On ILLEGAL Immigration Black People Politics 2
Destee Science and Technology : Vietnam Says Bitcoin Transactions are Illegal Science and Technology 6
Clyde C Coger Jr Health and Wellness : 5 Foods That Could Become Illegal With FDA Move to Ban Trans Fats Black Health and Wellness 90
Kemetstry Law Forum : REVENGE PORN SOON TO BE ILLEGAL? Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 5
Destee Law Forum : When Marijuana was ILLEGAL it had a Black Face - Now that it's LEGAL it has a White Face ?! Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 52
Alarm Clock Ghana : Ghana Government Orders Illegal Chinese Miners to Leave Ghana 9
Destee Black People Politics : Senate Bill 'Breathe-Less" Makes it Illegal to Inhale Oxygen More Than Twice in a 30 Second Period Black People Politics 3
Destee Black People Politics : Collecting rainwater now illegal in many states as Big Government claims ownership over our water Black People Politics 6
Destee Black People Politics : Senate Bill S510 Makes it illegal to Grow, Share, Trade or Sell Homegrown Food Black People Politics 4
Shikamaru Black Money Business Jobs : Interesting Theory: Pre-Civil War Slavery was Illegal and Unconstitutional Black Money Business Jobs 6
Destee Law Forum : Is It Illegal for a Black Man to Videotape the Police? (lboogiez) Law Forum - Prisons - Gun Ownership 10
Kamau47 Black People : Now It's Illegal To Videotape Them? Black People Open Forum 28
M Black Entertainment : ILLEGAL BUSINESS Black Entertainment 0
R Black People : Illegal vote shuts down Howard University newspaper Black People Open Forum 2
G Haiti : "ILLEGAL PEOPLE":Haitians And Dominico-Haitians In The Dominican Republic Pan-Africanism - African Diaspora 1
D Illegal drugs can be harmless, report says Black Health and Wellness 0
I Black People : Help Illegal Immigrants, but boost blacks, too Black People Open Forum 114
Destee Black People : Kofi Annan: Iraq War Was Illegal Black People Open Forum 6
R Black People : Illegal Immigrants Black People Open Forum 5
Clyde C Coger Jr Health and Wellness : Look To The Yams: New Study Finds Africans, Caribbean Immigrants Healthier than African-Americans Black Health and Wellness 3
Clyde C Coger Jr Black People Politics : The Mass Deportation Of Black Immigrants That You Haven’t Heard About Black People Politics 11
jamesfrmphilly Black Money Business Jobs : how some immigrants find jobs.... Black Money Business Jobs 4
WhatNeedsToBeDone Black Education / Schools : African Immigrants have the highest educational attainment but the incomes don't match up Black Education / Schools 1
HODEE Black People : WE ARE ON THE INSIDE...What immigrants and foreigners say about America Black People Open Forum 2
WhatNeedsToBeDone Black People : Is it against SOME immigrants culture to say PLEASE or THANK YOU? Black People Open Forum 14
RAPTOR Black People Politics : Caribbean and African Immigrants Getting Blocked In New US Immigration Reform Bill Black People Politics 2
chuck Black People : Black Immigrants Increasing Number of Ivy League Students! Black People Open Forum 6
Ankhur Black People : About those African Immigrants Black People Open Forum 21
Amnat77 Black People : Fear of Immigrants Black People Open Forum 25
Ankhur Black People : Do immigrants view the US as a savior? Black People Open Forum 3
G Black People : Buchanan: Americans Should Consider Allowing Only White Immigrants Black People Open Forum 2
D Pan-Africanism : African Immigrants a Successful Bunch, But Not Overall Pan-Africanism - African Diaspora 14
P Black People : Immigrants seen not taking Americans' jobs Black People Open Forum 5
S Black People : Question---Immigrants Black People Open Forum 6
D Liberia : Liberian Immigrants And NYPD Work To Improve Relationship Liberia 0
P Africa : Spain repels African immigrants All Things Africa 0
P Africa : OVERCOMING PERCEPTIONS: African immigrants seek ties, harmony with American blacks All Things Africa 30
A Pan-Africanism : African Immigrants Make Presence Known in U.S. Pan-Africanism - African Diaspora 5
Z Pan-Africanism : Tensions Increase Between US-Born African Americans and Black Immigrants Pan-Africanism - African Diaspora 43
Similar threads

Latest profile posts

Cheryl Fitts wrote on Destee's profile.
I am looking for participants in a study to share their experiences as former African American males served as ED/EBD/BD in the southeast. Participants ages 18-35 will be interviewed and given the opportunity to express their thoughts, feelings and impressions of their school years. If interested or for more information please contact me directly. Thanks, Cheryl
Cheryl Fitts wrote on Destee's profile.
Thank you for the welcome. I have a question. I am a doctorate student in need of participants for my study. Is it allowable to post a request for study participants. If so, this is the post that would be uploaded:
Let's us all remember in 2021 to protect our energy and to do the best we can to grow and evolve.
Queen Destee im back still showing lo e after what 20+ yrs? You know always stop through from time to time
Destee wrote on rhymebad's profile.
@rhymebad ... i love you ... :love: ... what was going wrong about polls and being blocked and stuff?