Black People : Hate crimes are different


Well-Known Member
Oct 25, 2005
What is a hate crime? This brother breaks it down for us.

Leonard Pitts: Hate crimes are different
By Leonard Pitts
Published 12:01 am PDT Friday, June 16, 2006
Seventy-six years ago, thousands of people came to lynch James Cameron.

In this, he was not unique. An estimated 4,700 Americans -- the vast majority of them black men -- suffered that fate in the years between the Civil War and the Civil Rights Movement. Here's what makes Cameron different: He survived, even though the rope was around his neck and the mob howling for his blood. He is believed to be the only person ever to do so.

James Cameron died Sunday at age 92 after years of failing health.

I met him in 1994 when I went to Milwaukee to do a story on his book, "A Time of Terror," and he told me about that awful night in August 1930. How police arrested him for a crime he had not committed: the murder of a white man. How they literally stomped him into signing a confession he was not allowed to read. How the dead man's bloody shirt was hoisted to a flagpole outside the jailhouse and all day long, a mob gathered beneath. How a false rumor spread that Cameron and two others had raped the dead man's girlfriend. How the mob attacked the jail after dark, taking sledgehammers to the door until their hands were dripping blood. How they beat one man, Thomas Shipp, to death. How they rammed a crowbar through another, Abram Smith. How they wrapped Shipp's body in a Klan robe and strung both corpses up in a tree. How they came for Cameron, beat him senseless and snugged a rope around his neck. How he was delivered by a miracle. Cameron says a voice -- he always said it was God -- told the crowd he had committed no crime. And just like that, they let him go.

After the interview, I drove down to Marion, the tiny north-central Indiana town where it happened. At that point, the lynching was 64 years past. Yet people changed when you brought it up. The crime haunted that place like ghosts, hung over it like smoke. As 93-year-old Jack Edwards, who was mayor in 1930, told me: "We're ashamed of it. It'll never be erased."

In 1988, Cameron founded what he called America's Black Holocaust Museum -- a Milwaukee institution dedicated to commemorating the years of racial violence. An obituary this week in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel says the museum has never attracted the number of visitors Cameron had hoped. Small wonder. Black or white, these are passages we find too raw and painful and "close" for remembering. Easier to turn away, spare our delicate sensibilities.

As it happens, I had intended to use today's column to respond to remarks from some of my readers about a different hate crime. Recently, I wrote about the case of a white man in New York City who had beaten a black man with a baseball bat while yelling racial slurs. Because of the slurs, prosecutors argued the white man should face enhanced penalties under hate crime statutes.

Some of you had a problem with that and, indeed, with the entire concept of hate crimes. You argued that a beating is a beating is a beating and the penalties ought not differ based on who is beaten or why.

I can appreciate why that reasoning seems to make sense. But it's built upon a fallacy: that a hate crime is just like any other crime except for motivation. Cameron's life and near death tell us differently. Your average crime victimizes only the victim and his or her family and friends. A hate crime terrorizes an entire people.

So you can't tell me that what happened to Shipp and Smith was only murder. Or that what happened to Cameron was only assault. Or that the person who burns a cross on a lawn is guilty only of trespass or the one who spray paints swastikas on a synagogue wall has committed only vandalism.

For 76 years, James Cameron told us otherwise. The ghosts of Marion still do.

About the writer:

* Leonard Pitts Jr., winner of a Pulitzer Prize for commentary, is a columnist for the Miami Herald. Reach him at; toll-free phone, (888) 251-4407. His column routinely appears in The Bee Friday and occasionally on other days. Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune Information Services.


Support, the oldest, most respectful, online black community in the world - PayPal or CashApp

Latest profile posts

Happy Thanksgiving everyone hope all is well
cherryblossom wrote on Joyce's profile.
Hello, Joyce! So sorry I missed you in 2020. Please come on back!