Three reviews saying the book is about racism, means what exactly, that you agree with the reviews? Any time Black People focus on achieving equity, or the mistreatment faced for generations, or racism in general, there will be those that scream racism back at us. In fact,
Trump is talking about giving white people reparations for DEI. I'm not sure what these reviews mean to you.
I read that book, for the first time, when I was 9 years old. In discussions of literature you will find the term "metaphor" used quite often. I doubt that I knew the word metaphor when I was nine but that Nourse was making an analogy to racism seemed pretty clear at the time.
I probably mentioned the 3 reviews to imply that it was not any bias from me that came up with that interpretation.
What the story was literally about was an alien, a Garvian, coming to Earth to be trained as a doctor. For some reason humans had a near monopoly on medical expertise. This is absurd but Nourse was a doctor so he created stories related to medicine. Anyway lots of humans were opposed to an alien learning their "secrets". So lots of comparisons can be made to this like making it illegal to teach ****** to read.
Another childhood experience was growing up with two sisters, 4 and 5 years older than me. I was sick of hearing about slavery and the word slave before I graduated from grammar school. Somehow they talked about it as though it was Black men's fault. I remember thinking, "What am I supposed to do? Invent a Time Machine and go back and fix it?
I tend to think in terms of POWER!
Economic Power Games
Military Power Games
Political Power Games
Women often think that they can play Sexual Power Games. They want some man to come up with money for whatever, clothes, restaurants. They seem to think of the money as spent on them while I think of it as throwing the money back at the White man for ********. I know a Black woman who bought a new car with insurance money from her husband's death.
And of course technology comes into it.
Who was
Hiram Maxim? Did he ever kill anybody? He was an American who went to England and invented the machine gun. Of course no one knows the name of the first person killed with a machine gun but we are pretty certain that it had to be a Black man in the first Matabele War in South Africa where British and other Europeans were carving up Africa.
Slavery is merely the most extreme form of economic servitude. Having to Pay these White people to live on this land that they annihilated the Indians to steal is slavery. So where have Black Leaders been saying that Accounting/Finance should be mandatory in the schools for Black kids since Sputnik?
So the issue is Economic Power Games and Economic Servitude not SLAVERY.
Consumer Slavery is Stupid!
Was that post long enough?
PS: Mr. Spock was the only human being on the Enterprise. ROFL
PS2: Of course if the issue moves to the level of Military Power Games things change significantly. But it reminds me that one of the complaints that my mother had about my father after years of divorce was guns in house. I remember 4 or 5 rifles or shotguns in the closet in his bedroom. I would spend weekends with him. To me a gun is just another machine, like an electric can opener. It is just a matter of circumstances.