Haiti : Black in Latin America (Haiti & the Dominican Republic: An Island Divided)

blackeyes

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
May 14, 2003
Messages
1,744
Reaction score
448
Location
South,Ga
It's very interesting that in the dr "black"=haitian.
I know many black americans who think "haitian"=the darkest black people on earth, where did that come from...Thomas Jefferson.lol


But yeah, I think it was pretty balanced. But I wish he had gone into more detail about Haiti occupying DR.
And it did seem like he was all smiles when talking about how black and proud Haitians are. But when he was in DR it just looked like he wanted to shake his head like..."these amber/brown people are crazy as hayel"lol

lol they put the drop quad on half an island.smh
 

Omowale Jabali

The Cosmic Journeyman
MEMBER
Joined
Sep 29, 2005
Messages
21,130
Reaction score
9,461
Location
Temple of Kali, Yubaland
It's very interesting that in the dr "black"=haitian.
I know many black americans who think "haitian"=the darkest black people on earth, where did that come from...Thomas Jefferson.lol


But yeah, I think it was pretty balanced. But I wish he had gone into more detail about Haiti occupying DR.
And it did seem like he was all smiles when talking about how black and proud Haitians are. But when he was in DR it just looked like he wanted to shake his head like..."these amber/brown people are crazy as hayel"lol

lol they put the drop quad on half an island.smh
Ironically though, the documentary seemed to imply that the DR assisted Haiti with a "humanitarian" effort after the earthquake without mentioning how the DR has at the same time been rather repressive towards Haitian refugees who migrated to the DR.

I did not see the entire program. It seemed to focus at one point on Papa Doc but virtually no mention of how repressive Trujillo was on the Black population in the DR.

And I do not recall any mention of Baby Doc and the millions the Duvalier family stole.

In fact, Papa Doc seemed to think it was funny that he was considered a dictator. That was a little more than I could take.
 

abstract219

...standing on the shoulders of giants
MEMBER
Joined
Sep 21, 2005
Messages
2,502
Reaction score
529
Location
Philadelphia PA
I think Prof. Gates(and his team) did a great job, what do you think? I thought it very balanced ..waiting for bientempo to comment..:qqb011:
I watched it. It was interesting. I thought Skip and his team did a aight job. My uncles told me DR is very Euro. Its time someone looked at the issue. Like Omowale stated, the show kinda glossed over the effect of Trujillo and US's current interventionist agendas.
 

bientempo

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
Oct 11, 2009
Messages
850
Reaction score
168
Location
Dominican Republic
Why

I think Prof. Gates(and his team) did a great job, what do you think? I thought it very balanced ..waiting for bientempo to comment..:qqb011:
As my cable company here does not do PBS and I don't like youtube, I have not see this. But why should I comment, obviously a Harvard Professor with an agenda knows much more than people that live on this island(either side). Maybe he can make this the subject at the next beer summit? We put very little credibility to those from the USA that come here to tell us how things are.
 

Amnat77

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
Dec 11, 2006
Messages
5,428
Reaction score
2,620
Location
UK..not for long
As my cable company here does not do PBS and I don't like youtube, I have not see this. But why should I comment, obviously a Harvard Professor with an agenda knows much more than people that live on this island(either side). Maybe he can make this the subject at the next beer summit? We put very little credibility to those from the USA that come here to tell us how things are.
Why are you getting so defensive, you've been hanging around Americans too long?:SuN031: You live on the island, and you are from there... so i was looking for your input as to how DR was portrayed ...i was just telling a FB friend that i really don't understand why black folks are so obsessed with finding out if DR peeps (now cape verde ) recognize their african heritage or not..i mean who cares? It's not like you lot have some great army like China, and are h%ll bent on killing anyone who is darker than a brown paper bag..I don't get it... i think it is some kind of inferiority/narcissistic complex... but folks will die first before they admit to that..

when you do get a chance to watch it, i would still like your input....

and oh btw... he did show folks on DR who practice african spirituality, and readily talk about their african heritage...
 

blackeyes

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
May 14, 2003
Messages
1,744
Reaction score
448
Location
South,Ga
Why are you getting so defensive, you've been hanging around Americans too long?:SuN031: You live on the island, and you are from there... so i was looking for your input as to how DR was portrayed ...i was just telling a FB friend that i really don't understand why black folks are so obsessed with finding out if DR peeps (now cape verde ) recognize their african heritage or not..i mean who cares? It's not like you lot have some great army like China, and are h%ll bent on killing anyone who is darker than a brown paper bag..I don't get it... i think it is some kind of inferiority/narcissistic complex... but folks will die first before they admit to that..when you do get a chance to watch it, i would still like your input....

and oh btw... he did show folks on DR who practice african spirituality, and readily talk about their african heritage...
I was wondering the exact same thing, I am pretty sure it's an inferiority complex. Some black folks will cut you if you dare say ur amber/brown behind ain't black.lol On another site some chick got a 'tude because I posted a website showing egyptians w/ both straight/"caucasian" and nappy/"afro" hair. It's kinda funny and pathetic at the same time.lol

I actually liked the program but black folks should stop harassing dominicans about how they view themselves.
 

bientempo

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
Oct 11, 2009
Messages
850
Reaction score
168
Location
Dominican Republic
Not Defensive

Why are you getting so defensive, you've been hanging around Americans too long?:SuN031: You live on the island, and you are from there... so i was looking for your input as to how DR was portrayed ...i was just telling a FB friend that i really don't understand why black folks are so obsessed with finding out if DR peeps (now cape verde ) recognize their african heritage or not..i mean who cares? It's not like you lot have some great army like China, and are h%ll bent on killing anyone who is darker than a brown paper bag..I don't get it... i think it is some kind of inferiority/narcissistic complex... but folks will die first before they admit to that..

when you do get a chance to watch it, i would still like your input....

and oh btw... he did show folks on DR who practice african spirituality, and readily talk about their african heritage...
Will not do any good for me to discuss this as most have already made up their mind about it any way, and nothing I could say will change what they have read or think. Therefore no sense in trying, I don't normally go around beating my head against a wall. From what I hear there are lots of things left out glossed over etc. but the only ones that know this are the ones that live on the island, both sides.

Has anyone done this for Greek, Turkish Cypriot? there is another island separated by custom, language, heritage.

As for the comment about the DR's Humanitarian effort after the earthquake, we still have thousands either in our hospitals, or aid stations, we are actually doing something instead of like the other countries talking about it. Yes we deport illegals, but so do other countries. 1600 dominicans from the USA in the last 6 months. Do I think the USA should have kept them no they are not citizens and they broke the law send them back!
 

chuck

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
Aug 9, 2003
Messages
13,683
Reaction score
2,153
As my cable company here does not do PBS and I don't like youtube, I have not see this. But why should I comment, obviously a Harvard Professor with an agenda knows much more than people that live on this island(either side). Maybe he can make this the subject at the next beer summit? We put very little credibility to those from the USA that come here to tell us how things are.
:SuN013:
 

chuck

Well-Known Member
MEMBER
Joined
Aug 9, 2003
Messages
13,683
Reaction score
2,153
Will not do any good for me to discuss this as most have already made up their mind about it any way, and nothing I could say will change what they have read or think. Therefore no sense in trying, I don't normally go around beating my head against a wall. From what I hear there are lots of things left out glossed over etc. but the only ones that know this are the ones that live on the island, both sides.

Has anyone done this for Greek, Turkish Cypriot? there is another island separated by custom, language, heritage.

As for the comment about the DR's Humanitarian effort after the earthquake, we still have thousands either in our hospitals, or aid stations, we are actually doing something instead of like the other countries talking about it. Yes we deport illegals, but so do other countries. 1600 dominicans from the USA in the last 6 months. Do I think the USA should have kept them no they are not citizens and they broke the law send them back!
You can never guess in advance who is reading what you're posting with an open not closed mind...

Do give me and others who also post on these forums our choice and our right to make up our own minds too...

:SuN044:
 
Top